Balancing elementary school enrollment and creating an intermediate school mean 28% of Portage Township Schools students will go to a different building next year, Associate Superintendent Michael Stephens said Monday.
The new boundaries were approved by the Portage Township School Board on Monday as part of a great reshuffling of students, faculty and facilities.
“We have a downward trend in our enrollment. We wanted to right-size,” Stephens told the board. A declining birth rate has affected schools across the country.
The district is closing Aylesworth Elementary School at the end of this school year, then razing it to make way for a new Aylesworth Middle School. That in turn has spurred a major reorganization of grade levels.
What’s now Fegely Middle School will become an intermediate school serving grades four and five. The current Willowcreek Middle School will serve grades six and seven.
That groups students whose developmental stages are closer to each other. Stephens recalls having eighth graders nearly age 16 – old enough to drive – grouped with fifth graders who are closer to fourth grade kids, developmentally, in the same building.
And the boundaries for the remaining elementary schools are shifting to make enrollments more even, with three sections of each grade at every school but one, Stephens said.
In drafting the new school boundaries, the district wanted to address transportation issues including travel times; prevent any school from being “underutilized,” which state law prohibits; and factor in Title 1 needs as well as future enrollment.
Several new subdivisions are being built on Portage’s south side, expected to bring an influx of new students to the district.
Under the new district boundaries, Crisman Elementary School’s territory sprawls across much of the northern part of the township, which is Indiana Dunes National Park land or heavily commercial and industrial. “The others are very well balanced,” he said.
A map shows the new boundaries for Portage Township elementary schools beginning next Aug.. (Portage Township Schools/provided)
South Haven’s boundary will be more compact, instead of sprawling across the width of the township. Myers Elementary’s boundary will shift to include the southwest corner of the township. Others will change as well.
Six of the seven elementary schools will have 312 to 373 students next year, Stephens said, making them as close in enrollment size as possible.
“In doing that, approximately 28% of this year’s K-12 students will find their way to a different school,” he said.
Teachers will be shuffled, too, as the grade levels change. Seniority is being factored in, but so is specialized training they might have.
“No one will lose a job. They will have a position here at Portage Township Schools,” Stephens said.
Superintendent Amanda Alaniz said three fifth-grade teachers wanted to stay at the same building because they’re close to retirement, and three third- and fourth-grade teachers wanted to move up. That swap will work out well, she said.
Fegely Middle School Principal Ann Marie Caballero will shift to Willowcreek Middle School. Willowcreek Principal Pat Mills will shift to Fegely Intermediate School.
“There’s a lot of excitement at all different levels,” Stephens said.
However, there’s a lot of concern about how this will all work out. “None of that has been done without some trepidation and concern and some worry,” he said.
The district has been holding a series of meetings to get faculty input as well as keep them informed about what’s going on. That’s going to ramp up with Monday’s board approval.
“We hope that we have allayed some fears, but we will continue to have those huddles” with teachers in grades five, six and seven, Stephens said.
Communications Director Melissa Deavers began sending emails to affected groups during the meeting, as soon as the board voted to approve the reorganization plan.
This will be the first time to have all fifth graders in a single building and all sixth graders together, Stephens said.
The intermediate and middle school students will have their bus times backed up 10 minutes next year, but others will stay on the same schedules, Stephens said.
Families of kids in grades K-3 who will shift to a different school will be informed individually.
The district is planning after-school opportunities for teachers to meet with their new principals to get to know them and “help start some of that organic growth they have,” Stephens said.
Open houses to meet the new teachers and new principals in the new schools are also being planned.
“I know it’s taken a lot of work to figure this out and put it all together,” Board President Any Maletta said. “None of this happened with a knee-jerk reaction.”
He’s especially excited about the new middle school to be built. “We haven’t had one of those in Portage for a very, very long time.” Portage High School, which opened in 1979, is the district’s newest school.
Doug Ross is a freelance reporter for the Post-Tribune.
https://www.chicagotribune.com/2025/10/28/new-portage-school-boundaries/