A groundbreaking Daily News series’ real impact

An op-ed in these pages five days ago by Robert Wexler recalled how a six-part series I co-wrote with William Heffernan in the Daily News which concluded exactly 50 years ago today had triggered changes in the city’s failing foster care system. He also provided insight into how the system operates today.

I was glad to learn about those changes — particularly the fact that agencies are no longer paid for each day they hold a child in foster care. In addition, the number of children each agency now receives is predicated upon their performance. Those are key changes because we had found that foster care agencies deliberately kept children in foster care so they would keep getting paid. The moment they place a child with an adoptive family, they were no longer paid.

But what I was shocked to learn in speaking with Wexler, executive director of the National Coalition for Child Protection Reform, is that this change came about only recently in the latest contracts the agencies signed with the city.

When we wrote our story with the help of Assistant City Editor William Federici, there were about 26,000 children in the city’s child care system. That figure climbed to nearly 50,000 in 1993 but has now dropped to about 6,500.

As we pointed out, these children are wards of the city and state — children for whom permanent homes are supposedly being sought. But we found that the foster care agencies that contracted with the city to find these children permanent homes instead systematically denied them that opportunity.

As a result, these children remained in foster care — many throughout their adolescent years — just so the private agencies could collect millions of tax dollars for their care. The agencies were supposed to work with the parents of these children in an attempt to rehabilitate them. Only if that effort failed or if the parents died or disappeared were the agencies expected to find adoptive homes for the children.

Our investigation found that a large number of the private agencies deliberately kept the children in their care and out of the adoption market, making little or no effort to rehabilitate their parents. Thus, the agencies were able to collect millions in child-care payments from the city. In fact, we found that fully 47 of the city’s 77 private agencies actually provided no adoption services at all. As a result, in 1974 only 3% of foster children were placed in adoptive homes.

Thus, one agency, Geer, A Children’s Community in Millbrook, recorded no adoptions in 1974 even though it had 326 children in its care. Speedwell Services for Children, Inc. in Manhattan had 577 children in its care and only four of its children were adopted in 1974. Cardinal McCloskey School and Home in White Plains reported five adoptions in 1974 out of 495 children. And St. Vincent’s Hall in Brooklyn listed one adoption in 1974 out of 725 children in its care.

Records showed that these four agencies — whose job it was to find permanent homes for the children in their care — were paid more than $6 million by the city in 1974. A spokesman for the city’s 77 child-care agencies insisted that no child was denied an adoptive home.

We also found evidence that foster care children were often neglected, abused, beaten and even sexually molested. In addition, we discovered that neither the city nor private agencies checked the backgrounds of foster parents for possible criminal child-abuse records before placing children in those foster homes.

In addition, we learned that some private agencies skimped on support payments to foster families, as well as the food and clothing they provided the children. And some falsified records to the city to claim payments for children no longer in their care.

And most shockingly, the city, which paid $100 million a year to private agencies to care for foster children, made little effort to learn how the children were being cared for or how the money was being spent.

Although Joseph Gavrin, executive director of the New York State Council of Voluntary Child Care Agencies, representing 72 of the city’s private agencies, said the average age of those in child care was 7 and that private agencies “have experienced great difficulty” finding adoptive homes for them.

But we learned from caseworkers that agencies repeatedly discouraged couples from adopting children, often by simply saying that the child was “too fond of its foster parents.”

Let’s hope child care agencies today look out for their children’s best interests.

Ain, a Daily News reporter from 1969 to 1990, was a staff writer for the New York Jewish Week and a columnist for The New Times. For more than 40 years he has hosted the weekly cable TV program “Jewish Life” and is a co-author of “The Living Memories Project: Legacies That Last.”

https://www.nydailynews.com/2025/05/18/a-groundbreaking-daily-news-series-real-impact/